Adjusted thresholds

South Asian BMI Thresholds: What Australian Guidance Publishes

Overweight starts at BMI 23 and obesity at 27.5 for South Asian family background. Where those numbers come from, and who is not on the list.

Australian guidance uses lower BMI thresholds for people of South Asian family background. Overweight starts at BMI 23 rather than 25, and obesity at 27.5 rather than 30. The RACGP publishes those figures in its Red Book, and NICE publishes the same two numbers.

Australian guidance uses lower BMI thresholds for people of South Asian family background. Overweight starts at BMI 23 rather than 25, and obesity at 27.5 rather than 30. The RACGP publishes those figures, and they apply to family background, not to where you were born.

This page reports what Australian and UK guidance publishes and nothing more. It gives no advice and does not tell you what your own reading means. For the standard bands, see what a healthy weight range means.

If weight, food or numbers start to feel hard, tell your doctor or another health professional you trust. Free, confidential help is also there. Call the Butterfly Foundation National Helpline on 1800 33 4673, open 8am to midnight AEST, 7 days. Call Lifeline on 13 11 14, any hour.

What Are the South Asian BMI Thresholds in Australia?

The RACGP's Guidelines for preventive activities in general practice, the Red Book, sets them out in its overweight and obesity chapter. It names six family backgrounds together: South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African and African Caribbean. It says people in these groups are prone to central adiposity, so their cardiometabolic risk occurs at a lower BMI.

Overweight

— BMI 23 to 27.4

Obesity

— BMI 27.5 or above

Compare that with the general-population bands of 25 to 29.9 for overweight and 30 or above for obesity. The gap is 2 BMI points at the overweight line and 2.5 at the obesity line.

The Red Book describes the lower figures as a practical measure of overweight and obesity. That wording matters. They change the point at which a clinical conversation starts. They are not a separate disease definition.

Does the Red Book Say This Anywhere Else?

Yes, and the second place is narrower. The Red Book's diabetes chapter sets screening rules for adults at very high risk of type 2 diabetes. Its footnote on BMI gives the general figure as 25 or above. It then says the specific cut-off points recommended for South Asian and South-east Asian people are above 23 for overweight and above 27.5 for obesity.

So South Asian background appears twice: once in a six-group list in the overweight chapter, and once named specifically in the diabetes screening footnote. Both give the same two numbers.

Where Do 23 and 27.5 Come From?

The figures trace to a World Health Organization expert consultation on appropriate BMI for Asian populations. Its cut points are 18.5 to 22.9 for normal weight, 23 to 27.5 for overweight, and 27.5 or above for obesity.

The underlying evidence is about where risk starts climbing, not about a different kind of body. NICE reviewed the same literature for its 2025 obesity guideline. It reported that studies in people of South Asian and Chinese family background showed increased risk at a BMI of 21 to 26. For people of White family background the same studies showed increased risk at 25 to 29. The published thresholds sit inside those ranges.

Key point

NICE found evidence for lower thresholds in other backgrounds too. Those were Middle Eastern (Arab and Iranian), Black African, Black Caribbean, and other Asian (Japanese, Korean and Thai). Across those groups, risk increased at BMI values from 21 to 30, but most were below 25.

Are South Asians the Highest-Risk Asian Group?

The evidence does not support saying so. A 2014 analysis in Prev Med (2014;65:1–6) applied the WHO Asian cut points across six Asian American subgroups. South Asian participants had 60.6 per cent overweight or obesity. Their diabetes rate in the BMI 23 to 24.9 band was higher than the non-Hispanic White comparison. But self-reported type 2 diabetes overall was 4.9 per cent among South Asians against 12.7 per cent among Filipinos.

That paper names Filipino, Vietnamese, Japanese, Korean and South Asian groups together as priority populations for screening. It does not rank South Asian risk above the rest. Pages that imply otherwise are overstating what was found.

Key point

It also notes the WHO Asian cut points are not recommended as clinical screening guidelines in the United States. Australia and the UK both use them. That difference is real and worth knowing.

What About Obesity Classes 2 and 3?

Both the Red Book and NICE handle this by subtraction rather than by a separate table. For these family backgrounds, the general thresholds are reduced by 2.5. NICE spells out the result: class 2 moves to roughly 32.5, and class 3 to 37.5.

NICE is explicit that it found no direct evidence for those two class thresholds in these groups. The 2.5 reduction is committee consensus and good practice, not a measured boundary.

Which Groups Are Not on the Lower-Threshold List?

This is the part most pages get wrong. The six-group list does not include Māori or Pacific Islander backgrounds. Neither the Red Book's overweight chapter nor NICE's recommendation 1.9.11 names them.

That is not the same as saying risk is low. The Red Book's diabetes chapter lists Māori and Pacific Islander people among high-risk ethnicities and backgrounds for type 2 diabetes screening. That list also names Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander, South Asian, South-east Asian, North African, Latin American and Middle Eastern people. So those backgrounds appear on the diabetes screening list while not appearing on the BMI threshold list.

The honest reading is narrow. Australian guidance has published an adjusted BMI figure for some backgrounds and not for others. Absence from the list means no published number, not evidence of lower risk. The ethnicity guidelines page covers the rest of the groups.

Does Waist Measurement Change Too?

The published waist thresholds in the Red Book do not vary by ethnicity. They are 94cm and above for men and 80cm and above for women for increased risk, and 102cm and 88cm for greatly increased risk.

Waist does something BMI cannot, though, and that is the point of the lower thresholds. The concern in these groups is central adiposity, which is fat carried around the abdomen, and a waist measurement reads that directly. The waist measurement guide sets out where the tape goes.

What This Page Cannot Tell You

Three things, stated plainly.

A threshold is not a diagnosis. Crossing 23 does not mean something is wrong, and staying under it does not mean nothing is. Only a practitioner who assesses you can say what a reading means for you.

The list is of family backgrounds, not nationalities. It does not ask where you were born or which passport you hold, and no guidance explains how to apply it to mixed background.

Key point

These figures were set for screening. They tell a clinician when to look harder. They were never designed to label an individual body.

Questions About South Asian BMI Thresholds

Under the published thresholds, yes. Overweight runs from 23 to 27.4 for South Asian family background, against 25 to 29.9 for the general population. A BMI of 24 sits inside the first range and below the second.

27.5 or above. The RACGP Red Book publishes that figure in two separate chapters, and NICE recommendation 1.9.11 gives the same number.

No. A child's result is a percentile for their age and sex, not a band, which the children and teenagers page explains. The lower adult thresholds are published for adults.

The 2014 Prev Med analysis notes they are not recommended there as clinical screening guidelines. It cites American Diabetes Association, USPSTF and NIH positions. Australia and the UK do use them. The research base is the same; the guidance differs.

The RACGP Red Book, overweight and obesity chapter and diabetes chapter, and NICE guideline NG246. Both are listed on our sources.

To see where a reading sits against both sets of bands, use the BMI calculator, and the BMI chart for the general-population bands.

No published guidance answers this. The RACGP and NICE both describe family background rather than a proportion, and neither explains how to apply the thresholds to mixed background. A GP decides which figure to work from after assessing you.