South Asian

Asian BMI and Ethnicity: The Cut-Offs Australia Publishes

People of South Asian background can carry more body fat, and more health risk, at the same BMI as the standard categories suggest.

If weight, food or numbers start to feel hard

Food, weight and numbers can start to feel stressful. If that happens, tell your doctor or another health professional you trust. Free, confidential help is also there. Call the Butterfly Foundation National Helpline on 1800 33 4673, open 8am to midnight AEST, 7 days. Call Lifeline on 13 11 14, any hour.

Why the Standard Categories Do Not Fit Every Population

BMI is a ratio of weight to height squared. It contains no information about what the weight is made of or where it sits, and both of those vary systematically between populations.

The specific pattern that drives the adjustment is this. At the same BMI, some populations carry more body fat, and more of it in the abdomen, than mainly European populations behind the standard categories. Abdominal fat is the deposit most strongly associated with type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. So two adults at a BMI of 26, from different backgrounds, can sit at clearly different metabolic risk.

That is not a flaw in the arithmetic. It is a limit on what a single weight-to-height ratio can carry. The same limit shows up when BMI is applied to athletes, to older adults and across the different life stages.

Key point

The response in clinical practice has been to keep the formula and move the thresholds. Australia does this in two places, and they are worth separating because they apply to different things.

The Lower BMI Thresholds Australian Guidance Publishes

The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners publishes preventive activities guidance for general practice. It states that people with a South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African Caribbean family background are prone to central adiposity. It adds that their cardiometabolic risk occurs at a lower BMI. It sets lower thresholds accordingly.

  • South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African and African Caribbean backgrounds. Overweight from BMI 23 to 27.4, obesity from 27.5.
  • General population thresholds. Overweight from BMI 25 to 29.9, obesity from 30.

Four things about those figures.

They are a practical screening measure, not a different disease definition

The guidance describes the lower figures as a practical measure of overweight and obesity for these groups. They change the point at which a conversation starts.

The list is of family backgrounds, not nationalities or birthplaces

An adult born in Melbourne to South Asian parents is inside the guidance. An adult born in Asia with no Asian ancestry is a question for a GP, not a calculator.

The gap is roughly two BMI points at the first threshold and 2.5 at the second

At 1.70m that is around six kilograms, which is enough to move a substantial number of people across a line.

Groups not on that list are not thereby low risk

The list reflects where the evidence was strong enough to set a number. Absence from it is not a finding.

Asian Population BMI Cut-Offs

For adults of Asian family background the practical consequence is a narrower healthy band.

Instead of 18.5 to 24.9, the band runs to just under 23. A BMI of 24, ordinary under the standard categories, sits inside the overweight range under the adjusted ones. A BMI of 28, which the standard table calls overweight, reaches the obesity threshold.

It does not mean a BMI of 24 is a diagnosis. It means the screening conversation the standard table would defer until 25 starts earlier, and that a waist measurement alongside it carries more weight.

Key point

The BMI calculator applies the standard Australian bands, because those are the published default. If you fall into one of the groups above, read your result against the adjusted figures on this page, take a waist measurement too. Then discuss both with a GP.

South Asian Metabolic Risk and BMI Thresholds

South Asian family background is one of the six on the RACGP list. It is also named on its own in the Red Book's diabetes screening footnote. The pattern documented in this population is a higher share of body fat at a given BMI, and more of it in the abdomen.

The detail, including where 23 and 27.5 come from and which groups are left off, is on the South Asian BMI thresholds page.

Pacific Islander and Polynesian Australians: What the Guidance Says

This group is handled differently in Australian guidance, and the position there is less settled.

Pacific Islander and Polynesian populations are not on the RACGP list of backgrounds given lower BMI thresholds. Several studies in these populations report a higher share of lean mass at a given BMI. That points towards higher thresholds rather than lower ones. Yet diabetes and cardiovascular disease prevalence in these communities is high. Those two findings pull in opposite directions, and no Australian source sets a population-specific BMI number.

Australian practice does adjust the waist measurement for these groups, which the next section covers.

Key point

Until a BMI figure is published, an adult of Pacific Islander or Polynesian background is best read three ways. Use the standard bands, a waist measurement and a GP conversation. A BMI in the overweight band may reflect muscle. The body fat percentage calculator and the lean body mass calculator both speak to that question more directly than BMI does.

BMI Calculator

Your body mass index and the WHO category it falls in.

cm
kg
24.2Healthy weight

Example shown: height 170 cm, weight 70 kg. Change the numbers to see your own result.

This is a screening tool, not a diagnosis.

The Waist Thresholds Australian Diabetes Screening Uses

The clearest population-specific numbers in Australian practice are waist measurements, not BMI. They sit inside a tool many Australians have already completed at a GP appointment.

The Australian Type 2 Diabetes Risk Assessment Tool, published by the Australian Government, scores waist circumference against two different sets of categories. The tool sets one set for people of Asian, Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander background and another for everyone else.

Men, lowest band

Under 90cm for Asian, Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander background; under 102cm for all others.

Men, middle band

90 to 100cm; 102 to 110cm for all others.

Men, highest band

Over 100cm; over 110cm for all others.

Women, lowest band

Under 80cm; under 88cm for all others.

Women, middle band

80 to 90cm; 88 to 100cm for all others.

Women, highest band

Over 90cm; over 100cm for all others.

Note what this is and is not. These are scoring bands inside a diabetes risk tool. They differ from the general waist thresholds Healthdirect publishes for increased and much increased risk. They are shown here because they are the clearest published evidence that Australian screening treats waist thresholds as population-dependent.

The waist measurement guide covers the landmark and the mistakes that shift the result.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Context

The approach here is different. No adjusted BMI number is published. The NACCHO and RACGP National guide keeps the standard bands and attaches two cautions. Many chronic conditions begin at a lower BMI, and waist circumference is a more sensitive measure of risk than BMI alone.

The prevalence figures, the National guide's combined BMI and waist table, and the survey caveats are on the First Nations BMI and waist page.

Why Australia Publishes Adjusted Thresholds, Not Adjusted Categories

A distinction that explains most of the confusion on this topic.

The BMI classification itself has not been rewritten. There is one Australian table of categories, and it is the same table for everyone. What the guidance does is tell clinicians to apply lower trigger points for particular family backgrounds when using BMI as a screening measure. The category names are unchanged and the thresholds at which they are applied move.

It means a calculator can legitimately show you the standard bands and still be correct, because those bands are the published classification. The adjustment is a reading layer applied on top, the same way percentile charts are the reading layer for children.

Key point

And it means the adjusted figures are a starting point for a conversation instead of a label. A South Asian adult at a BMI of 24 has not been reclassified as overweight in any register. Australian guidance simply considers 24 worth discussing in that person.

Which Number Should You Use

A short answer, because the sections above are long.

If your family background is on the RACGP list, use the adjusted BMI thresholds on this page and take a waist measurement. If it is Pacific Islander or Polynesian, use the standard bands and take a waist measurement. Treat a reading in the overweight band as a question about composition. If you are Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, use the standard bands with waist measurement given greater weight. If none of those applies, the standard bands and the published waist thresholds are your figures.

Take a waist measurement in all four cases. That is the one instruction every Australian source on this page agrees on.

Published Australian criteria sit on Australian medical standards.

What This Page Does Not Do

It does not diagnose anything. Every threshold here is a screening trigger, a point at which a conversation becomes worthwhile.

It does not cover mixed ancestry, because no Australian source does. An adult with parents from two of the groups above has no published threshold. A GP is better placed than a table to decide which comparison is more informative.

And it does not replace the measurements a clinician can take. Blood pressure, fasting glucose or HbA1c, and a lipid profile carry information no body measurement does. BMI and disease risk sets out what the published associations actually show.

Questions About Adjusted Cut-Offs

Australian preventive care guidance sets lower BMI thresholds for several family backgrounds. For people of South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African Caribbean background, overweight starts at 23 and obesity at 27.5. This is because heart and metabolic risk in these groups occurs at a lower BMI.

Under the adjusted Australian thresholds the healthy band ends just below 23 instead of 25. So a BMI of 23 or above is treated as overweight and 27.5 or above as obesity. A waist measurement alongside the BMI figure carries particular weight in this group.

The BMI category boundaries are the same. Australian guidance notes that many chronic conditions begin at a lower BMI for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. It treats waist size as a more sensitive measure of risk than BMI alone. Diabetes screening also uses lower waist bands.

Because BMI cannot see where fat sits, and abdominal fat drives most of the metabolic risk. A BMI inside the healthy band with a waist above the relevant threshold is a recognised pattern. It is more common in several of the population groups covered on this page.

Sources

  • WHO Expert Consultation, “Appropriate body-mass index for Asian populations and its implications for policy and intervention strategies”, The Lancet 363 (2004)
  • International Diabetes Federation, The IDF consensus worldwide definition of the metabolic syndrome (2006)
  • World Health Organization, Obesity: preventing and managing the global epidemic, WHO Technical Report Series 894 (2000): adult BMI classification

General information only. BMI is a screening tool, not a diagnosis, and nothing on this page replaces advice from a doctor or other qualified health professional.

Use the number as context, not a verdict.

Explore all calculators