Limited mobility
BMI Without Standing: Height Estimates and Limited Mobility
When someone cannot stand on a scale or against a height rule, BMI is worked out from substitute measurements. Height is estimated from ulna length, demispan or knee height. Weight comes from a chair or hoist scale. Limb loss is corrected with a published table. Each substitute widens the margin of error.
If weight, food or numbers start to feel hard
Food, weight and numbers can start to feel stressful. If that happens, tell your doctor or another health professional you trust. Free, confidential help is also there. Call the Butterfly Foundation National Helpline on 1800 33 4673, open 8am to midnight AEST, 7 days. Call Lifeline on 13 11 14, any hour.
Why the Standard Method Breaks Down
BMI needs two measurements, and both assume a body that can stand on a scale and against a stadiometer.
That assumption fails for a lot of people. Someone who uses a wheelchair full time cannot have standing height measured. Someone with a spinal curve has a standing height that does not reflect their frame. Someone who has lost a limb weighs less than their body would otherwise, and the formula reads that as a lower BMI.
None of this makes the person unmeasurable. It means the usual inputs need a substitute, and clinical practice has worked out substitutes for each case.
Estimating Height Without Standing
Three proxy measurements are in common use. Each one is converted to an estimated height using a published table, and the table differs by age and sex.
Ulna length
The ulna is the forearm bone on the little-finger side. It is measured from the point of the elbow to the bony lump at the wrist, with the arm folded across the chest. It is the quickest of the three and the one most hospital screening tools use.
Demispan
Demispan is measured from the midpoint of the breastbone notch to the web between the middle and ring fingers, with the arm held out sideways. It needs the person to be able to raise one arm.
Knee height
Knee height is measured from the sole of the foot to the top of the thigh. The knee and ankle are both bent at a right angle. It needs a special calliper and is mostly used in aged care and research.
All three estimate the same thing, and they do not always agree with each other. A difference of two or three centimetres between methods is ordinary, and because height is squared, that moves the resulting BMI by about a point.
Weighing Without a Standing Scale
Two options, and both need equipment the person may not have at home.
A chair scale weighs someone seated. A hoist or bed scale weighs someone who cannot transfer. Both are routine in hospitals and aged care, and neither is something most households own.
If no scale is available, a BMI cannot be calculated at all. This matters more than it sounds, because a screening tool with no number is often simply skipped. Where that happens, the alternatives below are what clinical services use instead.
When a Limb Is Missing
Limb loss lowers measured weight without changing anything about the rest of the body, so the raw BMI reads low.
The correction works in two directions. A clinician can estimate what the person would weigh with the limb present, then calculate BMI from that. Or they can leave the weight alone and raise the BMI thresholds instead. Each service uses one published table or the other, and the two approaches do not give identical answers.
The size of the correction depends on which limb and how much of it. A whole leg accounts for a far larger share of body weight than a hand. Because the figures vary between published tables, this is a calculation to have done by the treating service rather than at home.
What Clinicians Use When BMI Will Not Work
Several measures sidestep the height problem altogether.
Waist circumference
needs no height at all and can be taken seated or lying, although a lying measurement is not comparable with a standing one. The waist measurement guide covers the technique.
Mid-upper arm circumference
is a single tape measurement around the upper arm, used widely in nutrition screening where weight and height are both unavailable.
Weight change over time
is often more useful than any single reading. An unplanned loss or gain is a signal in its own right, whatever the BMI happens to be.
Clinical assessment
Skin, muscle bulk, appetite, strength and function tell a clinician things no index can.
How Reliable Is an Adjusted BMI?
Less reliable than an ordinary one, and an ordinary one is already a screening measure rather than a diagnosis.
Every adjustment adds its own margin of error on top of the limits BMI already carries. An estimated height carries the error of the proxy measurement. An adjusted weight carries the error of the published table. Squaring the height multiplies the first of those.
So the adjusted figure is worth having, and it is worth treating as a rough band rather than a precise value. A result close to a boundary should not be read as though it settles anything. The page on how BMI is calculated sets out the limits that apply to every result, adjusted or not.
Is Obesity a Disability in Australia?
It can be, depending on the circumstances, and the question is a legal one rather than a clinical one.
The Disability Discrimination Act 1992 defines disability broadly. It covers a condition affecting body function, and it covers conditions that are present, past, future or imputed. Whether a particular person's circumstances meet that definition turns on the facts of their case.
This is general information, not legal advice. Anyone who needs an answer for an employment, education or service-access situation should speak with a lawyer or a community legal centre.
Questions About Measuring When Standing Is Not Possible
Yes, using an estimated height from ulna length, demispan or knee height, and a weight from a chair or hoist scale. The result carries more uncertainty than a standard BMI. Many services treat waist circumference or arm circumference as the more practical measure.
No single one is best for everyone. Ulna length is the quickest and most widely used in Australian hospital screening. Knee height is often preferred in older adults. What matters most is using the same method each time, so readings can be compared.
Yes. A prosthesis adds weight that is not body tissue, so a weight taken while wearing one is not the same as body weight. Record whether it was worn, and keep that consistent between readings.
It is better done with your treating team. The published tables differ, and the choice between adjusting weight and adjusting thresholds changes the answer. The margin of error is wide enough that a self-calculated figure can mislead. Bring your measurements to the appointment instead.
More questions, answered on the page that covers them:
Check where you sit
BMI Calculator
Your body mass index and the WHO category it falls in.
Example shown: height 170 cm, weight 70 kg. Change the numbers to see your own result.
This is a screening tool, not a diagnosis.
Calculator ecosystem